tripleS celebrated their first music present win on “The Present” with their track “Women By no means Die” on Might 14, 2024. Regardless of the emotional acceptance speech and overwhelming reactions from the members, their encore stage garnered adverse reactions from Korean netizens.
A put up on TheQoo shared a tweet exhibiting the encore stage, the place all 24 members carried out collectively. Critics centered on the group’s reside vocal expertise, suggesting that with such numerous members, there needs to be no less than one expert singer.
The efficiency was in comparison with a highschool retreat because of the group’s synchronized singing of the refrain and quick particular person elements.
Critics argued that tripleS needs to be thought-about artists slightly than idols as idols are anticipated to excel in singing.
They felt that the idea of tripleS was extra depending on the variety of members and visuals than on expertise. One member, Chaeyeon, was significantly criticized for letting out an ear-piercing scream in the course of the efficiency, which disrupted the in any other case candy tone.
Whereas netizens acknowledged her pleasure, they questioned the need of the shout. The controversy highlights the discrepancy between tripleS’s visible attraction and their vocal efficiency. Whereas followers celebrated their victory, critics questioned the group’s suitability as idols based mostly on their vocal skill.
The dialogue extends to broader debates inside the Ok-pop trade in regards to the expectations positioned on idol teams and the emphasis on visuals versus expertise.
As tripleS navigates its newfound success, it faces challenges in balancing its picture as an artist with its viewers’s expectations for vocal high quality.
The incident is a reminder of the complexity of the Ok-pop trade, the place success is measured not solely by efficiency, but additionally by the notion of expertise and authenticity amongst followers and critics alike.
